One of the horror genre's "most widely read critics" (Rue Morgue # 68), "an accomplished film journalist" (Comic Buyer's Guide #1535), and the award-winning author of Horror Films of the 1980s (2007), The Rock and Roll Film Encyclopedia (2007) and Horror Films of the 1970s (2002), John Kenneth Muir, presents his blog on film, television and nostalgia, named one of the Top 100 Film Studies Blog on the Net.
Star Trek Anniversary - John's Top 20: "The Corbomite Maneuver" (#2)
At #2 on my list is "The Corbomite Maneuver," a classic episode of Star Trek. If I could show a non-fan just one episode to "characterize" the series, it would be this installment. I'm putting it at second, because there's one episode I prefer over it, but "The Corbomite Maneuver" could be the perfect template or prototype for Star Trek storytelling.
the third day of a star mapping mission in previously uncharted space, The
U.S.S. Enterprise is blocked by a cube: a border marker, apparently, left
behind by some unknown alien race.
Kirk (William Shatner) is forced to destroy the cube when it emits dangerous
levels of radiation and threatens the lives of his crew and the safety of the
long, however, the powerful force behind that cube arrives to confront the
Enterprise. Commanded by the fearsome Balok (Ted Cassidy) is a colossal vessel
-- the Fesarius – hailing from a society called The First Federation.
threatens to destroy the Enterprise for trespassing in restricted space. No
escape is possible. No plea is acceptable, he says.
the bridge of the Enterprise, Balok’s uncompromising behavior rattles the
nerves of a young navigator, Bailey (Anthony Call), and stymies Kirk’s attempts
at diplomacy. There seems to be no way to escape destruction, at least until Mr.
Spock (Leonard Nimoy) off-handedly mentions chess.
Kirk realizes he is playing the wrong game with this opponent. He adopts a
different game -- poker -- and then, with the straightest of poker faces,
attempts to bluff Balok.
ploy succeeds, and opens up a channel of communication between the Enterprise
months back, I was asked by a reader here on the blog to pick just one episode that
I felt could represent the totality of the Star Trek (1966-1969) experience.
selected “The Corbomite Maneuver.”
a doubt, this is one of the greatest episodes of the series -- one of the ten best -- and an
installment that delivers drama, suspense, and most importantly, a distinctive and
uplifting philosophical world view.
of all, “The Corbomite Maneuver” presents the idea that the greatest enemy in
space is not alien races, but fear itself.
In other words, human psychology. The problem is how we respond to that which we don't fully comprehend or know.
“The greatest danger facing us is ourselves,”
Kirk announces to the crew in this episode. He then
discusses “an irrational fear of the
unknown,” and notes that there is actually no such thing as the unknown,
rather merely “things temporarily hidden,
temporarily not understood.”
is a remarkable monologue, and a perfect distillation of Star Trek philosophy.
men and women of the 23rd century and aboard the Enterprise are equipped to handle new
frontiers, new civilizations. And what is unknown or seems different, in due time, becomes
understood, explainable. They are explorers who -- if they can conquer their own
demons -- are ready to meet the universe.
This is a great affirmation of mankind, and our potential. Star Trek shows us who we can aspire to be, if we put anger and fear behind us.
assertion of this philosophy is developed in the episode on an individual basis too; by Bailey, the young navigator who finds it difficult to control his fear, his
emotions when Balok threatens the Enterprise.
Bailey is young, and
inexperienced, and unlike the senior crew has not yet learned how to manage his
fear. He is well-trained, responsible, and capable...but personally, he grapples with the unknown.
At the end of the episode, Kirk notes that he “owes” Bailey a look at “the
face of the unknown” and it’s a remarkable moment. Kirk has taken him under his
wing, and shows Bailey that as captain he does not just mouth a philosophy of exploration,
peace and understanding…he practices it. He lives it.
In my opinion, this quality is what makes Kirk (and certainly Kirk of the first season) an extraordinary captain and role model.
very idea of fear is reinforced in the episode through the character of Balok as well.
He has constructed a menacing
puppet (replete with menacing voice…) as his “alter ego.” This is the face he shows the world...the universe.
Balok is so fearful of
alien contact that might go wrong, that the very face he puts on is one of sheer terror.At the end of the episode, Balok declares it "was a pleasure” testing the Enterprise and her captain (a common
Roddenberry theme, actually), but it is clear that the First Federation (Balok's governing entity) operates from a position of fear, hiding behind technology and masks to suss out the characteristics of other races.Given their diminutive personal stature, this
is perhaps an understandable philosophy too. They present as terrifying, lest they be seen as weak.
first episode of Star Trek filmed following the second pilot, “The Corbomite
Maneuver” also establishes a long-lived Kirk/Spock character dynamic. Specifically, Spock makes an observation or analysis about
a current situation or dilemma, and that remark inspires Kirk to concoct a brilliant, but spontaneous strategy for success.
Here, Spock is reminded of chess, noting that Kirk and
Balok keep making effective counter-moves.That notation gives Kirk the inspiration of a different game, poker…and bluffing.
As late as The Wrath of Khan (1982),
and Spock’s observation of Khan’s “pattern” indicating “two dimensional
thinking,” we see this character dynamic re-asserted.Spock observe and assesses; Kirk synthesizes
that work into purposeful, life-saving action. One man is all about knowledge and information. The other man is all about improvising survival from that analysis.
There are so many grounds upon which one can
commend “The Corbomite Maneuver.” It is excellent entertainment, first off, with a surprising ending.
More trenchantly -- and like
other early episodes of the series (namely “The Man Trap,” “Charlie X” and “The
Naked Time,”) -- this episode creates the impression of real people functioning on a real
I termed this the “the lower decks” paradigm in my reviews of those episodes.
Here, for instance, we see Yeoman Rand bringing Kirk dinner (while he gripes
about a diet), and meet a young surrogate for the audience: Bailey.
Bailey, like the audience, doesn’t quite know
the ropes. This episode is his journey. In a way, he is really the central character of this work of art. No, he’s not a captain, a CMO or
exec. He’s just a kid promoted to a job of
great responsibility. But importantly, he is a individual who has no practical way of grappling with his fear.
When Kirk mentors him, he is really mentoring us too.
also find this episode exceptionally tense, and, indeed, a template, perhaps,
for many of the most challenging an remarkable episodes of Star Trek.
Much time is spent on the bridge, as strategy
is discussed and executed, and there are no planets to visit.
Think about how much Star
Trek: The Motion Picture (1979) resembles this story type. The crew --from their workaday control room -- grapples with alien contact. In the midst of an emergency, the crew must
face their fear of the unknown, and puzzle out the rationale behind an intelligence beyond human
of course, the answer in both cases is not violence. It is not hostility. It is
not to kill that which is different.
Instead, an episode such as “The Corbomite Maneuver” suggests that we
can control all those impulses and meet the unknown with the best angels of our
nature. Bailey sees the face of the unknown, and fear disappears.
Put aside your fear, says Star Trek, and that which is dark an mysterious, becomes
illuminated and known.