If nothing else, the new Fox TV series
Terra Nova from Brannon Braga and Steven Spielberg is a stark reminder that there are really two tiers of television entertainment or programming available these days.
On the first tier, you get nuanced, droll, dramatic, and highly-intellectual fare such as Dexter, The Walking Dead or True Blood.
And on the other tier, you end up with pandering, appeals-to-the-masses hokum such as Terra Nova.
This new sci-fi series, a superficial, rah-rah paean to the glories of the American nuclear family -- even in the Cretaceous Period -- is generic, as bland as they come, and slathered with relatively weak CGI special effects. As many critics have observed, the dinosaurs look pretty terrible. But then so do the CGI landscapes and cities.
Still, the effects aren't the biggest problem. The crisis for Terra Nova is that it is pitched so damn low in terms of intelligence, and even internal consistency.
The premise of
Terra Nova, as you likely know by now, is that by 2149 AD, man has all but destroyed Mother Earth. The atmosphere is polluted and virtually unbreathable. American citizens must wear "re-breathers" on a daily basis just to survive.
However, mankind of the 22nd century discovers he may get a second chance. A fracture in time-space has been detected, and so man of the future has begun to send "pilgrimages" back in time some 85 million years...to start over.
The discovery of this time fracture has also revealed that this gateway leads not to our own past; but to the past of
an alternate reality. Therefore, the people who go back in time are free to interfere in the affairs of the world without worrying about deleting their own histories from existence.
Of course, they may be interfering with alternate selves or other, innocent human beings, but no one bothers to bring up that point. If evolution unfolds as it does in our reality, the pilgrimages to Terra Nova are certainly usurping it.
The Shannon family, led by Jim (Jason O'Mara) and Elizabeth (Shelly Conn) are among those who travel back in time to Terra Nova for a "new dawn" for mankind. Getting there isn't easy, however. The parents have broken Federal laws concerning "population control" and given birth to a third child. When this child, Zoe, is discovered, Jim -- a cop -- is incarcerated. Two years later he breaks out of a maximum security prison to go back in time with his family and escape such restrictions.
Fortunately, the Shannons are warmly received by Commander Taylor (Stephen Lang) at Terra Nova, and quickly become top advisers to this charismatic military leader. Their teenage son, Josh (Landon Liboiron), however, proves quite rebellious and begins exploring outside the Terra Nova compound with other young adults. He does so despite the fact that dinosaurs called "slashers" roam freely about and like to feed on humans.
Meanwhile, Jim learns that there is unrest in Terra Nova, particularly from a group called "Sixers" (from the Sixth Pilgrimage). The Sixers often steal supplies from Taylor's community, and have staked out a nearby quarry where valuable minerals are located.
In the first two-part episode, "Genesis," the viewer is introduced to the Shannons, their world of 2149 AD, and the community of Terra Nova in the distant past. But for all the intriguing ideas evident in the premise, the show's big observations so far are all pure middle Americana sitcom: that teens will remain rebellious, even with dinosaurs about, and once-a-cop, always a cop. The drama doesn't go much deeper than that, at least not yet. And science fiction should be deep; it should be about examining the human equation from as many angles as possible.
And actually, Terra Nova plays on a dumber level than my critique above indicates. The series presents us with two basic facts that seem to have trouble co-existing. The first is that overpopulation is destroying our planet, and that rigorous laws have been established in an attempt to slow down overpopulation -- an unsustainable lifestyle -- as much as possible. Such laws limit a family membership to four.
And the second fact is that the Shannons, our protagonists and role models, have broken this law intentionally, and had a third child. Why, we are not informed.
Amazingly, the writers of Terra Nova are never smart enough to draw a straight line here connecting these facts. In the past, Taylor speaks of a new dawn for mankind, and how the old world was destroyed. He notes, particularly, that man "blew it," that "he destroyed our home." He did so, insists Taylor, through "greed and ignorance." Now, 85 million years in the past, he has a chance to start again.
But the problem is this: the Shannon family is held up as heroes by the series, yet they are among those who willfully helped to destroy the planet by intentionally disobeying the laws and edicts of their culture. Their world is in shambles...and they made it worse by breaking the laws regarding childbirth and personal responsibility.
And we're supposed to like and respect them.
At this point, I'm not sure why they, in particular, deserve a second chance. This show is so dumb that it doesn't even make the connection between the necessity of the population control law to PRESERVE LIFE ON EARTH and the fact that the Shannons wantonly broke it...but now get a second chance in the Garden of Eden anyway.
Instead, the "Population Control" officers of the government are portrayed here as black-booted thugs who interfere in the private affairs of families. These gestapo-styled soldiers enter a private home, turn it upside down, and find a hidden child. At first, I believed that this scenario might represent some kind of metaphor for illegal immigration, with the Shannons desperate to find a way to get to their new home, even if illegally, with the family intact.
But then I realized instead that the show is simply pandering to the selfish, myopic Tea Party mentality dominating our national discourse right now. In other words, government is made to look evil (and anti-family, and anti-life) for interfering with the affairs of private citizens.
And yet, as is abundantly plain, this is an immensely stupid argument. If you can't breathe the air, if the world is dying, the government of man must do something to save us, right? Something like imposing population controls. Given the dire environmental situation portrayed in Terra Nova, a limit of two children per family hardly seems unreasonable. Unlike Z.P.G (1972), for instance, there isn't a complete moratorium on child bearing here. This law is not even as draconian as a "one-child" policy. No, instead, the government in this series is just saying limit the family to two children.
But hey, that's taking away our freedom...to destroy the planet. I can hear the cries of "don't tread on me" already. And in this case, the people shouting that phrase will literally choke on it, as the air becomes unbreathable for everyone. What Terra Nova seems to indicate is that it is okay for the individual to defy the rules of the government -- rules made for the common good -- because they overstep some sense of personal liberty. This is Ayn Randianism gone nuts. Nobody seems to care about the common good anymore.
And again, this idea even seems embedded in the series premise. Terra Nova is a community not just in an alternate world, but an alternate past. By going there and interfering with history, the colonists are, essentially, dooming another human race (assuming similar evolution). How would we feel if aliens from a world that they ruined traveled to our past and colonized it, taking away not just our liberty, but our very existence? The more you think about it, Terra Nova is a program about very selfish people. And again, we have to ask, do they really deserve the second chance, a second world to ruin?
Frankly, I don't know if this conceit was intentional, or just a result of shoddy thinking, but so far Terra Nova is rife with these gaps in logic.
For instance, there have been ten pilgrimages back to the community of Terra Nova, and yet there is no sign or indication of a civilian government there. Instead, a military man, Commander Taylor, runs the entire show, without oversight. Now, with dinosaurs hopping around, I absolutely understand the need for a strong security force and a well-armed militia, but why doesn't one exist side-by-side with a citizen council? Do the people of Terra Nova realize they have traveled back in time to participate in...a military dictatorship?
That's their answer for escaping the restrictions of an overreaching government in 2149 AD...authoritarian military rule? There's your freedom for you.
With all the happy talk of a new beginning and a new dawn for humanity, you'd expect that
democracy might be one quality of America that would be exported to the Cretaceous Period, but apparently this is not the case.
Besides concerns such as these, the makers of this sci-fi series seem to work overtime to satisfy all audience demographics. That's where more of the pandering comes in.
In the span of a two-hour season premiere, the writers set up hunky/sexy prospective romantic partners for both the Shannon teenagers, for instance, thus assuring that teenagers will tune in. So in the first show, you get teens in love, bromides about families sticking together in tough times, a vicious dinosaur attack, and enough bad green-screening to last you a lifetime.
In terms of genre history, Terra Nova owes a big debt to Lost in Space, which concerned an American family contending with another dangerous frontier, outer space. Also, Lang's character and character history seems somewhat reminiscent of the actor's role in Avatar (2009). In terms of visuals, the series references both Stargate and The Time Tunnel with its temporal hardware.
Terra Nova may yet improve, and I hope it does. I'd like nothing more than to have a weekly engagement with intelligent science fiction television. The two-hour premiere sets up some interesting mysteries regarding the motivations of the Sixers, and Taylor's long-missing son, so I hope I have some cause for optimism.
I'm pretty disappointed with the opening chapter of this new drama, but I will keep watching, and keep hoping that Terra Nova transcends its TV tier...and begins to be a science fiction series worthy of the genre.
Posts
