V: The Final Battle (1984) is the second production in
the V
saga, and it originally ran for a whopping six hours over three nights, May 6 –
8, 1984.
If you’re keeping count, V: The Final Battle aired just a
month or two shy of thirty years ago, which is impossible for me to believe.
I vividly
remember watching this sequel mini-series on network TV with my parents and sister, and all of us
being glued to the set. The second mini-series also had its own water-cooler moment with the birth of the "Star Child" and her ill-fated sibling. At my school, everyone was talking about this sequence non-stop during lunch.
In terms of quality, however, V: The Final Battle
breaks down like this:
The first night -- which re-establishes the Kenneth Johnson
characters and diagrams the Resistance plot to expose Supreme Leader John (Richard
Herd) on live television -- is uniformly superb.
The second night -- which introduces Ham Tyler (Michael
Ironside) and culminates with the birth of Robin’s (Blair Tefkin) otherworldly
twins -- is pretty good.
And the last segment of the mini-series -- featuring the
defeat of the Visitors -- grows worse and less-satisfactory every minute it runs, culminating with a
seriously wrong-headed and poorly-conceived climactic scene.
The second V mini-series’ disappointing
denouement may be the result of a few crucial factors.
First, V’s creator, writer-director Kenneth
Johnson, had departed the franchise over disputes about its direction.
Secondly, there was no doubt pressure on the new writers to
deliver a happy ending for a scenario in which such a happy ending was
extremely unlikely. Even It
Can’t Happen Here didn’t have a happy ending. It ended with underground groups still attempting to take back a fascist America.
And third, resolutions of big, epic sagas like V
are notoriously hard-to-nail down, anyway. V: The Final Battle’s wrap-up is
unsatisfactory in much as the same way as Return of the Jedi’s (1983) wrap-up
is unsatisfactory.
You reach the end credits and you just can’t quite believe
that’s all there is.
A battle of galactic proportions is over, and here we are…with
Ewoks banging stormtrooper helmets like drums…
So overall, V: The Final Battle is mostly
pretty good -- if not always inspired -- work.
The mini-series succeeds admirably
when it introduces Ham Tyler, a necessary counter-balance to the “do-gooders”
in the Resistance. The mini-series also features
a few unforgettable set-pieces such as John’s unmasking, and finally, it
delivers juicy, unforgettable fates to the characters we all love to hate,
namely Daniel (David Packer), Eleanor (Neva Patterson) and Steven (Andrew
Prine).
In terms of theme, V: The Final Battle all but abandons
the discussion of fascism that informed V and instead -- at least momentarily -- tackles a different controversial
subject: abortion.
In the sequel’s unexpectedly most passionate and cerebral
scene, all sides of the issue are raised, vis-à-vis Robin and her pregnancy, and
the subject is discussed with remarkable verve, clarity and detail, and with
precious little judgment or preaching.
But the problem overall with V: The Final Battle is
that the focus of the drama has undeniably changed. V was It
Can’t Happen Here meets “To Serve Man,” and a brilliantly forged
meditation on the multitudinous ways that man might contend with a shift in the
existing social power structure.
By contrast, V: The Final Battle takes the whole
enterprise to a more mundane, soap-opera-like level where the focus is not on
collaborators or deniers, but on personal issues like….will Juliet and Mike
hook-up? Or, will Diana wrest control of the Visitor fleet away from Squad Commander
Pamela (Sarah Douglas)?
It’s a very different brand of storytelling; less
allegorical, and consequently less cerebral. In terms of my biases as a viewer and a reviewer, I prefer the original V's approach to drama.
For all its abundant excitement and other virtues (and there
are many…), V: The Final Battle just seems less realistic and three-dimensional
than its classic predecessor.
“We’re a Unit...We’ve made more noise than you have.”
In occupied Los Angeles, The Resistance launches a raid against a Visitor food-processing
plant, only to lose the day because the Visitors have improved their body
armor.
Re-grouping, the Resistance determines that it must undertake
a big, bold mission, lest sympathy turn away from it and towards Earth's occupiers.
To that end, Mike (Marc Singer), Julie (Faye Grant) and the
other fighters plan to reveal the Visitors’ true reptilian nature on live
television during a benefit at a Los Angeles hospital. John (Herd) is unmasked, and the mission is successful, but Julie is
captured afterwards. She is taken to Diana’s (Jane Badler) mothership for the harrowing and painful conversion process.
Soon, a professional soldier, Ham Tyler (Michael Ironside)
joins the L.A. Resistance, and informs the group of a world-wide organization of
fighters. He also supplies the team with new armor-piercing bullets.
After Donovan and Martin (Frank Ashmore) arrange to free
Julie from captivity, the Resistance must launch another daring raid, this one to prevent
the Visitors from “sucking dry” all of the water in California within 30 days. The mission is a success, though -- as always
– there are casualties.
While Julie grapples with her conversion experience, Robin
Maxwell gives birth to twins.The first appears human, save for a
forked-tongue. The other is reptilian,
and dies shortly after birth. Its death
gives Resistance scientists the clue they need to develop a toxin fatal to the
Visitors, the Red Dust.
While the Resistance plots a delivery system for the Red Dust,
Diana “retires” her new superior, Pamela (Douglas), and assumes control of the
fleet. When Diana realizes that she has
been outmaneuvered by the human resistance, she activates a Doomsday Weapon to destroy
the Earth…
“Enjoy your reign…Queen of the Poison Realm.”
V: The Final Battle starts off very strongly, with a
raid on a food processing center that goes awry for the Resistance. The Visitors have developed new
bullet-resistant armor, and are ready for the attack. The humans are beaten back...defeated.
This is a frighteningly good sequence and note to commence on because it re-establishes the desperation of the Resistance. In short, embedded power
accrues and consolidates more power. Since the Visitors have now been in power
longer, they are growing much stronger, while the Resistance struggles just to keep up.
The Visitors have more resources at their disposal, and are developing new
technologies to control Earth and its resources more effectively.
The elements of V: The Final Battle which function best tend to be on this front. After a major loss, the Resistance realizes it needs to do something “big” to
capture the hearts and minds of the Earthlings, and so it has to take a risk to
unmask John on live-TV.This brazen gambit involves underworld contacts, a break-in, and other interfaces with the criminal world, and so an important point about "resistance" is made: it has strange bedfellows.
Another commentary on the danger of life in the Resistance involves the mini-series' setting. V: The Final Battle features the Resistance almost constantly on the move. The L.A. organization has no less than three separate HQs
during the run of the mini-series, and that constant changing of venue
similarly suggests desperation. Being a "freedom fighter" in occupied territory means living life on the run.
To some extent, the introduction of Ham Tyler fits in with
this notion of desperation as well. A
man of few words -- and who cuts right through B.S. -- Ham Tyler is not a nice guy. He
is not an idealist, and he is not polite. Instead, he is a professional, covert soldier that
deploys the techniques that work, not the techniques that are moral.
If we are to believe fully in the V universe, it is
necessary to feature a character like Ham Tyler. One who relies on expedience, and has almost no self-doubt, or
recriminations about his approach. He is
a needed contrast to Julie and Mike, who are still fighting a war based on
issues of “what’s right” and “what’s human.”
Ham fights on the basis of how to quickly, brutally, and efficiently
destroy the enemy.
Ham is a great character, and Michael Ironside is terrific in
the role. There’s a great battle in Part
Two of V: The Final Battle, in which Ham alone takes down dozens of
Visitors while they invade the Resistance Base.
We hardly know Ham at this point,
and yet he commands attention, and the screen -- often the only human in frame -- and we are drawn
to him. We may not like his philosophy of life, or arrogance, but he's courageous. And most importantly...he's on our side.
V: The Final Battle is also enjoyable, frankly, because it so damned cut-throat. The characters whom we have grown to despise over ten hours get their comeuppance in the final act, and, I must confess, there's something very rewarding about seeing Daniel, Eleanor, Brian and Steven punished for their moral trespasses.
Daniel -- the most loathsome of all, in my opinion -- is framed...and served up on a platter. Eleanor gets shot in the back (after metaphorically stabbing Steven in the back). And Steven and Brian meet terrible ends due to exposure to the red dust.
Steven's death is the best filmed. We pull back to a high angle, and see that he has expired on a huge Visitor insignia, a metaphor for the approaching death of the occupation, perhaps.
The biggest problem with V: The Final Battle is
its conclusion. Julie, Mike, Lorraine (a
member of the Fifth Column) and Martin storm the control room of the Mothership
to confront Diana.
Elizabeth, “the Star
Child” is there, and has watched Diana murder John.
Diana has also set the mothership to explode using a doomsday
machine. The entire Earth is imperiled. But Lorraine can’t stop the program.
Meanwhile, Diana suddenly acquires powers of telepathy (!), and
convinces the “converted” Julie to let her steal away when no one is paying attention. Diana then pulls a Darth Vader, and escapes in her personal sky-fighter to return another day.
Back on the mothership, Elizabeth grips
the controls of the doomsday machine and de-activates it using some mystical
power that manifests itself as a glowing halo around her body.
After watching Elizabeth save the Earth, Mike and Julie share
a passionate kiss...
Besides the obvious problem of Diana developing telepathy
with a human -- a power her species doesn’t even use when with one another -- the big
concern here is the nature of Elizabeth’s sudden powers.
The
writers of V: The Final Battle have seen fit to give the saga a mystical, irrational conclusion, when mysticism has not at all been part of the V “universe” up to this point. We have not been prepared for its sudden
appearance (at…just…the…right…moment) in the drama and thus the resolution falls flat, and
worse, feels insulting.
In the introduction to this review, I called the
conclusion “wrong-headed,” and that’s for one crucial reason.
Many fascist
regimes incorporate myths of the supernatural or mystical into their
ideologies. Aryan blood isn’t just blood…it’s special, privileged, elite blood, and so
forth.
So for a franchise that concerns
the rise of a fascist state to resolve in a fashion that creates a mystical “super
being” like Elizabeth is not just weak storytelling, but the precise opposite of what should
occur. Taking down “fascism” should be the
purview of humanity, having learned its lesson that “it can happen here.”
Instead, we get a god-like figure of magical
powers to lead us out of the darkness. We are asked, essentially, to follow a magical superman figure rather than realize that if we want freedom...we make it for ourselves.
The instinct to seek such a super power is exactly what leads to the creation of a
fascist state in the first place. So not
only has V: The Final Battle picked a very bad way to end, it has picked the one way
that actually undercuts the very theme or message of the franchise the most.
The final images of Mike and Julie smooching in the control
room don’t really help to forge a satisfying ending, either. So…they’re in love. Is that Earth-shattering news, considering the Visitors have been driven from the planet, and millions of people are now taking their first breath of freedom?
The point is this: before V: The Final Battle, this franchise
wasn’t really a love story. Or at least the love story was so far back among the
list of dramatic priorities that it didn’t seem particularly important in the grand
scheme of things.
But V: The Final Battle ends with the (horrid) moment of misplaced mysticism, and the
spotlighted punctuation of the unimportant love story. It’s just a very disappointing turn for the V saga, if you ask
me.
Yet, in fairness to V: The Final Battle, there might be a
sub-textual motivation, at least, for the prominent Donovan-Julie kiss.
The entire V saga has been parsed as an
allegory for Nazi Germany. The Visitor insignia is a symbol not unlike the
swastika, and so forth. If this is indeed the
case, then the Donovan-Julie kiss at the end of V: The Final Battle could
be interpreted as a direct surrogate for the famous sailor/woman kiss
celebrating the end of World War II in Times Square.
If so, the kiss may be more appropriate an “end” for the saga
than it appears at first blush.
I wish I
could find a similar validity for the presence of the mysticism.
I like V: The Final Battle.
There's no doubt that it starts off strong, ad makes some good points about the desperation of Resistance.
I should also add that V: The Final Battle features a classic performance by Jane Badler as the scheming, selfish, power-hungry Diana. She is just a joy to watch.
There's so much that's good in the mini-series, and yet the ill-conceived end leaves a bad taste, and undercuts many of The Final Battle's most dramatic accomplishments.
In the rush to give us the happy ending it thinks we desire, the V saga loses a lot of the franchise's realistic luster, and we're left with what seems like a superficial blockbuster movie, instead of a dedicated, thoughtful science fiction vision about the rise (and fall) of a fascist state.
Perhaps they needed eight hours? Or, more aptly, a guy named Kenneth Johnson at the helm.
NBC should never have duked it out with Kenneth Johnson over the direction. Trust the creator. Maybe what he had planned wouldn't be as good as the original, but it had to be better than Final Battle. And that climax. Wow, we go from V to The Jetsons meets 2001. Such a huge letdown.
ReplyDeleteJohnson has said his version was the best thing he had ever written, even better than the original mini-series, he also stated his ending would have seen Martin sacrificing himself by piloting the mothership into deep space before it detonates, meanwhile Donovan and Julie take off in a shuttle in pursuit of Diana who had kidnapped Elizabeth (who had NO mystical powers, thank goodness!) and escaped in her shuttle craft to rendezvous with the rest of the Visitor fleet hiding behind the moon. Donovan's and Julie's shuttle manages to narrowly dock in the ship that Diana escaped to as the doors are closing... and that's the cliffhanger to be continued... although I personally would rather Johnson's would-be second 'V' mini-series had some kind of a definitive conclusion, even an open-ended one, rather than left unresolved for the next instalment, whatever form that would have taken.
DeleteI really wish Kenny Johnson had returned, but the studio screwed him over and broke the terms of their contract with him, and he was right to walk. Interestingly not long after the weekly series was mercifully cancelled, Warner Bros Television head Brandon Tartikoff personally admitted to Johnson he had been right all along and the studio should have done it his way.
Too late, alas...they played it cheap and ruined what could have been a brilliant sequel. I happen to like 'The Final Battle' despite it's flaws and evident cost-cutting (the studio demanded Johnson cut $5m from the sequel mini-series budget prior to him exiting), there's some show-stopping scenes, good performances all around, and Ham Tyler is just The Man... but you can't help thinking what might have been if Johnson had returned, alas...
"I wish I could find a similar validity for the presence of the mysticism."
ReplyDeleteYeah, I'm not very satisfied with it with it either. It just smacks of deus ex machina. But let me toss out a possible way to validate it. V is quite clearly a fascist parable, with most of the show's imagery being derived from Nazi Germany. As you rightly point out, the Nazis were consumed with mystical notions of blood purity, and the mixing of races was vigorously condemned (cf the Nazis and the idea of the Mischling, or crossbreed).
Bearing this in mind, the appearance of the messianic child (a hybrid mixture of both human and Visitor) might be seen as a kind of symbolic refutation of notions of blood purity. Instead of being a harbinger of degeneration and decline, the mischling actually becomes a symbol of a glorious future. Indeed, if memory serves (I haven't watched the show in some time), the Priest character actually brings the girl to Diana as a sign that the twp species could live together in some kind of harmony.
trajan23
Thank you, a very interesting review. A lot of things I didn't know about V.
ReplyDeleteI think (regarding the previous comment - which has it's point) that there is a diffence - while in Nazi Germany they tried to avoid intermarriages (going against the nature), the visitors' (Diana's goal) was to create such a mischling under the conditions, where it wouldn't be possible (going aginst the nature). The Visitors are not mystics, thy are technocrats. They use the knowledge they have, to exercise the power and control. I think the creators just started here (and continued in the TV series) to make mystical (and mythical) referencies because they thought it would be much more easily consumed by the auditorium.
Alas, we must disagree on Ham Tyler. Oh, he's badass, ruthless and witty, yes, a type of character we need to contrast with Mike and Julie, and Michael Ironside is incredible in the role, but he also represents the narrative and tonal shift from the futile struggles of the underdog to the victory of the weak-but-scrappy.
ReplyDeleteUp until this point the Resistance has been on the back foot. Their efforts are almost entirely ineffective - see the raid on the processing plant in part 1 - and their only success, unmasking John, is pyrrhic with the capture of Julie (but how great is it that slime Daniel is the one to catch her!?).
Ham brings the bullets which allow the Resistance to hurt their foe. He brings contact to (unseen) outside allies with the capabilities to manufacture and distribute, secretly, mass quantities of a complex biological agent. Ham, double handedly (along with Chris Farber) turns a rout into another pyrrhic victory. The Resistance may lose a base, but Ham guns down a dozen armored troopers with manly hip-fire sprays from an uzi-penis,and blows up the rest. (Hi, Dick Miller, bye Dick Miller.)
Ham is where the Resistance starts WINNING and winning big. His introduction begins the transformation from thoughtful allegory to action movie. From this point the Resistance gets anything they need. Uniforms! Voice modulators! Hot air balloons! Lasers! Bombs! Ok, blowing the water pipeline is satisfying, but, still...
The Red Dust works, conceptually. H. G. Wells would be proud. But, boy, it all happens so fast. The third episode feels like an acceleration of the narrative. It's literally Act III and it's time to wrap everything up. In an alternate universe there's a four-night version of the miniseries where the discovery of the Red Dust is the night three cliffhanger and the entire fourth episode is on its production and deployment. Maybe featuring a subplot where someone (lets make it Elias and Caleb, so Mike and Julie stay together and in LA) and Chris Farber (so Ham can stay with Mike and Julie in LA) travel with the Red Dust formula. Mayo Clinic in Phoenix so So Cal can double as AZ (thinking of the budget). Hell, we'll kill Caleb (who can live long enough to do the "I'm proud" scene) during the exciting return to LA with a shipment of completed Red Dust. V works well when it makes you like someone then kill them, and after Ham arrives they stopped doing that. This is easy-hindsight, but would fix pacing issues and keep layering characters while not having outside Resistance groups be magical offscreen armoriies. Doesn't change the end.
Ah, the end. Elizabeth. Others already wrote about the irony in allegory of the "half-blood" overcoming the "pure blood." Sure! But let's not ignore the lizard baby. The "inferior" (more lizard) half breed dies, but provides the key to the larger victory. The "superior" human dominant genes get magic powers. The possible anti eugenics statement almost becomes pro-eugenics. "Hybrid vigor," anyone?
I've not read Kenneth Johnson's "V: The Next Generation," but, as a guess, with the 20-year setup if the distress call, Elizabeth was meant to age normally, rather than molt into a five year old. She'd be a good age to move to prominence when the other aliens arrive...
Yeah, her magic powers at the end are just a mess. Final battle stars excellently, downgrades to Very Good in episode 2,drops to Good in episode 3 and collapses into What the Hell? in the final ten minutes. Still, overall a worthy classic.
Then the regular series falls apart.
Nerdy background actor observation, the visitor trying to escape wth Steven at the end (before he gets a mouthful of Death Paprika) and who Ham shoots, is the same guy Mike unmasks on the mothership at the very start and who he films. Same actor anyway. Sucks to be him!
ReplyDelete