We
now move from one of the
best Logan's Run episodes
("Crypt") to one of the absolute worst.
In "Fear Factor" -- a title that
presages a popular reality TV series of the 21st century -- our intrepid heroes
Logan (Gregory Harrison), Jessica (Heather Menzies) and REM (Donald Moffat) come
across a beautiful estate in the middle of nowhere, and also a strange woman
writhing around on the grounds in mortal fear. She seems to be suffering from
what REM diagnoses as "mind-numbing
trauma."
Logan, REM and Jessica return the woman to
the facility. They learn it is a mental hospital where the lead psychologist,
Dr. Rowan (Ed Nelson) is a psychopath himself. As the leader of the "Inner
Circle," he controls all the inmates (here known as "menials")
as well as the doctors at this "convalescent" sanitarium by forcing
upon them virtual lobotomies, crushing their "militant" independence
with his own thoughts.
Meeting Jessica and diagnosing her as a
revolutionary, Dr. Rowan feels she's a natural for the procedure. Logan and REM
attempt to intervene, but are dropped into a basement survival track, an
obstacle course which includes a wind-tunnel and an area where fireballs are
hurled at them. When they survive these trials, Rowan attempts to recruit
Logan, but he'll have no part of it.
Finally. Logan teams with another
psychologist, Dr. Paulson (The Fantastic Journey's Varian, Jared Martin!) to
topple this odd society. He does so not a moment too soon, because Dr. Rowan
wants to raise an army of re-programmed individuals...literally, since he has a
machine that can accelerate the growth of any human.
At the end of the day, REM -- stating my
feelings about this episode perfectly – notes: "I've had enough of this
place.”
I don’t blame him a bit.
My problem -- as I've elaborated upon
before in my reviews of the series -- is this recurring and absurd notion that
some little enclave of society like a lunatic asylum could continue to exist
unimpeded after a nuclear war. After
hundreds of years. Where
does this asylum generate its power? (Remember, there's no power grid). Yet
this facility has heat; it has light; it is technologically advanced and it
looks exactly like a 20th century asylum...out in the middle of nowhere.
I just find that these kind of stories are
unsupported from the standpoint of rationality. Where does this clinic get
patients, anyway? From runners who happen out of the City of Domes once in a
blue moon? And how are the doctors
trained? What medical schools do they attend?
Dr. Rowan notes that he has picked Dr. Paulson to succeed him, as though
it is a great and prestigious honor. How
many apprentices did he have to choose from?
And why would a mental sanitarium have a
basement obstacle course that shoots fire-balls and blows heavy wind at
patients? Again, this would seem to
require a lot of power, and it’s doubtful to me that a pre-holocaust facility
would have had this kind of room. There’s
also a trap door in a corridor that drops people into the fire/wind tunnel.
In short, there’s just no logical
underpinnings for this tale. At the very least, we might ask, who mows the lawn at this place, and with what equipment?
Also, the Star Trek variations are growing old. There was
a Logan's Run version of "Charlie X" ("The
Innocent"), a Logan's
Run version of
"The Enemy Within" ("Half Life") and now this is Logan's Run's version of "Dagger of the
Mind." In that tale (which, frankly, wasn’t very good), a mad scientist,
Dr. Adams (James Gregory) was experimenting on the minds of mental patients. Here
Rowan is doing the same thing, though at least he has a motive: world conquest.
He wants to build an army.
The most intriguing aspect of the episode
is the treatment of the Jessica character. She is characterized by Rowan (and
Logan) as a fiery rebel and independent thinker, which sounds more like Agutter’s
interpretation of the character, from the 1976 movie. Here, Jessica, who was
part of the underground in the City of Domes, notes that “If people think for themselves, it’s a threat to the system.”
To Rowan, this kind of thinking is indeed a
threat, and he plans to destroy Jessica’s mind. It’s clear he takes a special
delight in destroying her, because she has questioned him. This plot would have more power if we had
seen more of Jessica’s “fire” in the actual series. Already we have seen her immediately buy into an illusion of Sanctuary (“The
Collectors”), for instance, which doesn't say a lot for her critical thinking.. She has not
been written as the powerful rebel that the character originated as, which
makes the story-line in “Fear Factor” surprising, but welcome.
Looking across the Logan’s Run catalog,
one can see how several stories all fit the same thesis, of advanced and
complex states that should be helping people be better, but don’t help to do
that at all. Instead, they only subjugate or enslave people. We’ve seen the computer
installation of “Man out of Time,” an empty and baffling relic of another age,
the bunker for psychic research (“The Innocent”), the machine in “Half-Life”
and now the asylum in “Fear Factor.”
Many of these tales display a distrust of facilities/installations that
are designed explicitly to aid and heal. This is perfectly in keeping with early
1970's dystopian cinema, which often involved failed states, and failed state apparatus.
But what doesn’t make sense -- in all
these tales -- is that these facilities keep operating independently centuries
after the holocaust, still receiving power, personnel, and with technology
still functioning.
Next week, a better episode: “The Judas
Goat”
John, perfect review of "Fear Factor". I absolutely agree with your statement of "...facilities keep operating independently centuries after the holocaust, still receiving power, personnel, and with technology still functioning." This was a question that should have been explored by the writers. You are also correct about Jessica on the series is not written as this character was in the 1976 film, too bad.
ReplyDeleteSGB
John,
ReplyDeleteAlthough I've never watched this show (but loved the movie upon which it is based), I'm still enjoying reading your reviews of the episodes. I get the impression that the writers are struggling with budgetary issues; coming up with interesting ideas that don't cost too much, and leaning heavily on Star Trek's influence for how to achieve this. I'd love to watch this if it were streaming, but not sure if I want to pay real cash money for the dvd's. Regardless, I appreciate your thoughts on this series.
Steve