In
this episode of Star Blazers (1979), the great ship Argo tests its wave motion
engine for the first time.
In
the Central Strategy Room, Captain Avatar and his top crew strategize for space
warp, described aptly in the dialogue as a “giant
step across space.” The problem, as
everyone realizes is that if calculations are wrong by even a degree, the Argo
could become lost forever in the corridors of the “fourth dimension.”
The
region selected for the Argo’s first jump is “Area 14,” a span of territory between the Moon and Mars. Alas, a Gamilon carrier approaches the Argo
as it nears those coordinates, and Derek Wildstar launches a squadron of Argo’s
small fighters to intercept it. One ship
-- Conroy’s – nearly doesn’t make it back in time to join the Argo.
The
Argo succeeds on the jump, and reaches Mars in a matter of seconds. Unfortunately, the ship is badly damaged in
the jump, and the crew must undertake repairs before the Gamilons can locate
the battleship and resume their bombardment.
Only
362 days remain until Earth will be destroyed…
Between
this episode and the next, The Argo is getting a shakedown of sorts. The engine is tested here at space warp
capacity, and the follow-up episode involves the first deployment of the wave
motion gun.
Much
of this episode consists of building tension in terms of the first space warp
jump. Mark Venture is understandably concerned
and anxious, since he is Argo’s navigator, plotting the vessel’s trajectory through
space/ time. More suspense arises when
Conroy is almost left behind as the countdown to space warp ticks down. My friend SGB has written before in the
comments about the “emotional component” of Star Blazers, and this
scene certainly fits the bill. Once
again, as viewers we are asked to contemplate the notions of duty and sacrifice
in the service of a greater good.
Captain Avatar is prepared to leave a man behind because the
consequences of mission failure are, literally, global.
All
these moments work well, and the moment of space warp doesn’t disappoint,
either. The episode cuts to a trippy
montage of the ship crossing planes of existence, it seems. Images of the ship in flight double and
triple, and the Argo even seems to travel through the corridors of time…where
it briefly meets itself. It’s a pseudo-2001
visual “trip,” and as such, awesomely psychedelic.
Less
satisfactory, however, are the exact details of the space warp. It is reported in the dialogue that “thousands of light years” are traversed
in a matter of moments, but the Argo bafflingly emerges near (a snowy) planet
Mars. On average – because both it and the Earth move
-- Mars is some 225 million kilometers distant from our world. A light year is approximately 9.4605284 x 1012
kilometers in distance, so the Argo hardly jumped at all.
In
fact, it didn’t even jump one light year, let alone thousands, if Mars was its
destination.
Now,
I am not at all a person who believes that science fiction programs must be
entirely scientifically accurate to be enjoyable. In some sense, a focus on scientific accuracy
over drama can take the fun and imagination out of certain narratives. But, there should be some surface attention
paid to scientific accuracy. In other
words -- just on a general level – I know that Mars is not a light year
distant, let alone thousands of light years distant.
I
wonder if the original Japanese series made this error in science, or if it was
an error in translation to English. In other words, I wonder if in the Japanese
original, the planet the Argo jumps to is not actually Mars, but rather one
much more distant and far outside the solar system.
Regardless,
this is a jarring mistake that raises many distracting
questions. And that, generally speaking,
is my threshold of tolerance. I’m
willing to let pass a lot in the name of entertainment and imagination -- I’m a
die-hard Space: 1999 fan, after all -- but what does appear on screen
generally shouldn’t be so amiss that it actually distracts from the narrative.
What
makes the mistake worse is that in the follow-up episode, Argo travels from
Mars to Jupiter in a matter of minutes without using the wave motion star
drive. The distance from Mars to Jupiter
is approximately 3.18 AU or 419 million kilometers, which is greater than the
distance between Earth and Mars.
So
basically the Argo space warps to travel a shorter distance (Earth to Mars) and
conventional engines to traverse a longer one (Mars to Jupiter). Again, I ain’t
a science expert, but I know enough about space to be distracted by all this.
Despite
the goof, I still have “faith” in what Star Blazers is “doing,” to borrow a
line from Derek Wildstar. In particular,
I’m enjoying the series as momentum builds, and the Argo passes one crucial
test after the next as it begins its long journey.
John: It's good to see you continuing with this project. On the "thousands of light-years" goof - I suspect that it was more than just an error in translation, but that the offending line was invented out of whole cloth by the good folks at Griffin-Bacall, the advertising agency responsible for localizing the first two series of SB Yamato as Star Blazers.
ReplyDeleteWhile I was unable to find a fansub of episode 4, I do have the officially released subtitled version of the movie compilation of the Quest for Iscandar. The offending line isn't there, but since the movie is heavily edited, that conclusion can't be definitive.
The "tell" however that leads me to believe the line was never there in the original version is that we only see the back of Venture and Wildstar's heads looking out at Mars through the window when the line is delivered. There is no dialogue over the similar shot in the movie compilation.
There's a lot of quiet sequences in the Japanese version where the creators rely upon the visuals to get the message across that are covered by dialogue in the American version. I strongly suspect that this is one of those instances.
John good points regarding the technology use in your episode 4 review and thank you for the acknowledgement of my prior comments.
ReplyDeleteSGB