In
“Battle of the Titans” -- the final episode of Return to the Planet of the Apes
(1975) -- a desperate General Urko attempts to regain power in Ape City, while
the astronauts and Zira and Cornelius take the opportunity to bring peace to
the planet of the apes.
In
particular, Cornelius and Bill return to the icy mountain where they stashed
the book “A Day at the Zoo,” which revealed intelligent 20th century
humans and primitive apes in zoos.
After
recovering the text, the astronauts and the pacifist chimps prepare to present the
book to the Ape Senate…and to change a planet in the process.
Although
Return
to the Planet of the Apes sometimes succumbs to childish story-telling
instincts (and does so again in this final episode…), I nonetheless have great
appreciation for the animated series because the characters and situations don’t
remain locked in stasis. The episodes
aren’t interchangeable, and character and story arcs are, actually, present.
To
wit, the humanoids rescue their companion, Judy, from the Underdwellers during
the course of the series. They also find
the other human astronaut, Brent. They
acquire a weapon with which to defend the primitive humanoids in the form of a
World War II fighter plane. Additionally,
Urko attempts to seize power from Zaius, and then ultimately loses it.
And
finally, in “Battle of the Titans,” the series ends with the suggestion of another
tectonic shift; a chapter notably consisting of hope. In particular, the series comes to an end
with Cornelius preparing to reveal the truth about Earth’s history (and evolved
man…) to the Ape City Government. The
series thus culminates with the belief that humans and apes working together “can change the history of the planet…peacefully.”
That’s
a huge shift from the beginning of the series (and the other installments in
the movie and TV franchise), and away from Dr. Zaius’s admonition to Zira and
Cornelius that even the mere idea of intelligent human beings is enough to
warrant the genocide of the humanoids.
But
the animated series has traveled some distance since that statement of
principle, and some of that mileage includes Urko’s power grab. It is now entirely believable that the time
has come for change, and peace, and that many apes would be open to the notion.
So
“Battle of the Titans,” and Return to the Planet of the Apes
truly end on a note of strength.
Commendably,
this episode also features much continuity with previous episodes. We return to the Buddhist Apes and
mountaintop settings of “Terror on Ice Mountain,” and once more encounter the squawking,
flying monster from “Attack from the Clouds.”
Again,
this is a commendable and intelligent approach to children’s programming,
though, finally, watching a giant ape -- Kygor -- and a giant bird duke it out
hardly seems like the appropriate territory of a Planet of the Apes
series. This kind of monster fight, in
lieu of more solid science fiction concepts, is the kind of thing that keep the
series from reaching a level of universal approbation, I feel. The
fights are repetitious and not that interesting, and they eat up precious
screen time that could have been utilized to further wrap-up dangling plot
threads, or deepen characters.
Still,
it’s important to remember that this series aired in 1975, when concepts of
story arcs and serialized television series were not fully formed, let alone
for Saturday morning kid’s show.
There
are some franchise fans who prefer the cartoon series to the live-action
series, and that’s because, I believe, Return to the Planet of the
Apes actually shows momentum, movement and growth, whereas the
live-action series -- as much as I enjoy it -- seems stalled forever on ideas
of capture/escape, with very little new or original occurring episode to
episode.
So
in its own way, and with a few caveats for the nature of the thing (as a kid’s
show), Return to the Planet of the Apes is a real triumph for the
franchise, and I’m sorry to see that it didn’t lead into a second season. I would have loved to see the next chapter of
the saga…
John excellent review of “Battle of the Titans”. Return To The Planet Of The Apes 1975-1976 animated series is a far superior series to the prior year Planet Of The Apes 1974-1975 CBS live-action series for the very reasons you state that changes occurred. The live-action series on CBS never felt like they accomplished much. If it had been like this animated series it might have had a second season. That being said, Return To The Planet Of The Apes animated series should have had a second season.
ReplyDeleteSGB
I do much wish I could have seen if Apes in control, and not necessarily just the Ruling Body of the Senate, which seemed to be dominated by the species of Orangutans, could have actually been given rights of any sort (be they called human or otherwise) considering General Urko, acting General Rotok and all the other massive army of gorillas with their howitzers, jeeps, trucks and even rifles (although fortunately never been permitted to be used considering the Child Audience being targeted) could have had any decent chance of occurring.
Delete