A regular reader, Steven writes about Planet
of the Apes (1968):
“Like you John, I think this is one of the greatest science-fiction films
ever made, and which still holds up today.”
“In Planet of the Apes
(1968) after the astronauts splashdown in and abandon their A.N.S.A. spaceship
we see a clear blue sky as Taylor wanders with the others, speculating about
what this planet is and stating "...there is no moon...". We know
there was a nuclear war that devastated the surface of the Earth, but what
happened to the Moon? It is a clear blue sky and no moon at all. What do you
think?
“I know the answer that it blasted out of Earth orbit on September 13th,
1999 will be very tempting...”
Steven, you read
my mind about the Space: 1999 solution.
It’s clear to me
that Moonbase Alpha and the 311 scientists and astronauts stationed there
escaped the rise of the planet of the apes when the moon was blasted out of
orbit…
But seriously, I
think the most likely answer is that Taylor (Charlton Heston) is simply
mistaken about the presence of a moon.
He doesn’t see a
moon, but the moon is still there, obscured, perhaps, by the thick clouds we
see “glowing” later that night.
Another possible
answer is that the moon is itself destroyed.
Since the film takes place nearly 2,000 years from now, we could
speculate about a cosmic collision of some type, or perhaps even the moon
crashing into the Earth, a catastrophe which I suppose could account for some
of the desolate, inhospitable terrain of the Forbidden Zone and other areas.
If there were
one line of dialogue I would remove from Planet of the Apes, this “there is no moon” line would be a prime candidate, because in
retrospect is seems put there just to throw audiences off the track.
We believe that
this strange world can’t be Earth in part because Taylor has established there
is no moon.
It’s one of the few facts we
get during the course of the film that leads us to believe we actually are on a
faraway world. And of course, we’re
not. Taylor has come home.
Planet of the Apes features so many virtues, and yes, it is my favorite science fiction
film of all time. But if it came out
today with this line of dialogue intact, I might point it out in my review as a
kind of cheap way to maintain secrecy for the surprise ending. The funny thing is that the film could have
probably gotten away with not mentioning the moon at all. But then I guess
nitpickers would ask why Taylor doesn’t just look up at the moon and realize he
has come home to Earth…
Very interesting
question, my friend!
John thank you for answering this question with good insight. “There is no moon” is a line early in the film that does well at misleading the audience. If they had not said that then the audience would have said was the Moon in the sky? They are astronauts and should know it on sight. I think if the film was made today they probably would have CG added a weird thick cloud cover in the blue sky and still said “there is no moon”...after the Statue of Liberty scene the clouds clear the reveal the Moon.
ReplyDeleteHowever, I think your theory of the Moon destroyed is correct as it was in the Time Machine(2002). Albeit, the Space:1999 answer is good too.
Thanks again for answering my question.
SGB
Hi SGB,
DeleteI loved your question...it's a good one. I like the Space:1999 answer too... :)
As if the fact that the apes speak English wasn't a giveaway.
ReplyDeleteAnonymous,
DeleteWow! You must have never seen a science fiction movie.
Do denizens of other planets speak English in Star Wars? Star Trek? Etc?
English-speaking Apes is not a giveaway in POTA and you know it. Try not to leave snide comments, all right. Or if you do, be a grown-up and leave your initials or name.
best,
John
There's a ongoing POTA comic book series from Boom! Studios called Planet of the Apes: Cataclysm which answers what happened to the moon.
ReplyDeleteWhat was the explanation in POTA:Cataclysm?
DeleteSGB
Read it and find out ;)
DeleteBasically there was a war during the 2000 years that included a rocket being pointed at the moon
The apes figure this out and launch that nuclear missle
interesting thoughts regarding no moon:
ReplyDeletehttp://io9.com/what-if-the-earth-had-no-moon-489004464
SGB
John, I had totally forgotten about that "no moon" comment by Dodge, when I was re watching POTA again last year. It inspired me to spew forth a fanfic/ crossover. Posted on Ariane's sight, with illustrations courtesy of my daughter. Naturally I'd be interested in your review/ critique, if you have the time.
ReplyDeleteRegds, John M.
http://space1999fiction.com/story.asp?id=planet
The Space 1999 solution..some very intriguing, high quality fan fic.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.fanfiction.net/s/10033776/1/Planet-of-the-Alphans