Thursday, November 23, 2023

Doctor Who 60th Anniversary: "Curse of Fenric" (McCoy)


At the height of World War II, strange monsters emerge from the waters of Maiden’s Point.  

After their arrival, the Doctor (Sylvester McCoy) informs his teenage companion, Ace (Sophie Aldred)  that a nearby church is built on old Viking graves, and that some form of “evil” was once buried there.

When a blind scientist translates the rune-stones carved by those Vikings, however, the Ancient Evil awakens.  The Doctor -- who dealt with that evil, called Fenric, some seventeen centuries earlier -- must now stop it again. 

But Fenric is stronger than ever before and has summoned a blood-eating monster from Earth’s distant future, the Haemovore, to aid him.  

Now, the Haemovore begins turning humans into vampires, and threatens the very course of human history…


The Sylvester McCoy era of Doctor Who started with absolute ignominy.  His first story “Time and the Rani” is one of the worst and most embarrassing titles you’ll find in the entire Doctor Who catalog. After that debacle, the series then moved around aimlessly for a time, before finally settling upon a new idea for his tenure.  

And that new idea was a really great, really inventive one, because it intimated that the Doctor was not just some renegade Time Lord, but something else…something mysterious.  

He was a cosmic chess-player -- God Himself? -- battling for ownership of the universe.  This new, Seventh Doctor was a master manipulator too, heading knowingly into danger, and knowingly into situations that would help his companion, Ace (Sophie Aldred) grow as a human being. 

McCoy was downright masterful at appearing jovial and avuncular, but then, suddenly, showcasing this dark, cunning side. So all of the sudden -- and to quote a warning sign in "The Curse of Fenric" -- there were suddenly "dangerous undercurrents" again in Doctor Who.



While it is true that the production values, writing, and direction on the series were worse than ever during McCoy's reign, this new “lens” at the very least permitted audiences to parse the Doctor and his journeys in a new and inventive fashion.  

Sometimes, the new template didn’t work at all.  I will live happily the rest of my days if I never have to sit through “Ghost Light” again. 

But sometimes, the template worked absolutely brilliantly, as is surely the case in “Curse of Fenric.” I consider many serials of the McCoy Era absolutely unwatchable, but this serial --warts and all -- qualifies as a series masterpiece and high point of the Seventh Doctor's span. 

We learn in “The Curse of Fenric” that ages ago the Doctor played against Evil Itself in a game of chess.  

The Doctor won and sent Evil back to the shadow realms. But after generations, Evil has returned to take over the world.  What we get then in “Curse of Fenric” is a Manichean battle between the Doctor and his opposite, a battle between a force of light and the force of darkness.  I love the imagery that this game of chess evokes.  The notion of the Doctor on a desert plain, carving chess pieces out of bone is both mysterious and magical, and so the question is raised: Doctor Who?  

Is he a messiah? Mankind’s savior? An elemental force of good, as I noted above?  

A story like “The Curse of Fenric” succeeds because it gives us a new perspective on the entire series.  The Doctor’s “aimless” wandering is suddenly not so aimless at all.   Each time he lands the TARDIS, he is landing on a different chess board square, tipping over one of Evil's "players" or "pawns" if he is successful.


“Curse of Fenric” bristles with powerful ideas, and one of the most powerful involves a secular definition of faith.  

The Doctor reports that the Haemovores can be stopped by the power of complete faith.  Faith is not defined, however, as a belief in God, but rather boldly and unconventionally, as a total belief in anything an individual finds meaningful on a personal basis.  One Russian soldier repels the vampires with his unswerving belief in Marxism, for example.  

Touchingly, Ace uses her love for and faith in the Doctor to hold back the Haemovores.  

I love "Curse of Fenric's" notion, that “faith” can apply to something beyond the symbols of Christianity or organized religion.  Unwavering human belief -- in family, in friends, even in ideology -- is a powerful weapon, this serial suggests.

“The Curse of Fenric” is also wonderful in terms of Ace’s development as a character.  The Doctor has led her to this junction in time and space for a specific reason, and that reason is stunning.  The episode’s moment of catharsis -- when Ace dives into the waters of Maiden’s Point to cleanse herself of hatred (and self-hatred) -- is absolutely remarkable.  The moment is as touching as any in Doctor Who history.

Honestly, I can’t say very positive things about almost any Sylvester McCoy Era serials besides this one, but “The Curse of Fenric” gets to me each time I watch it.  If, somehow, the rest of the Seventh Doctor’s Era had been this good, perhaps Doctor Who would not have been canceled in 1989.

No comments:

Post a Comment

60 Years Ago: Goldfinger (1964) and the Perfect Bond Movie Model

Unlike many film critics, I do not count  Goldfinger  (1964) as the absolute “best” James Bond film of all-time. You can check out my rankin...